Movie Review
Iron Man
a.k.a. “Iron man - El hombre de hierro,” “A Vasember,” “Homem de Ferro”
MPAA Rating: PG-13for some intense sequences of sci-fi action and violence, and brief suggestive content

Reviewed by: Michael Karounos
CONTRIBUTOR

Better than Average
Moviemaking Quality:
star star star star ½
Primary Audience:
Kids, Teens, Adults
Genre:
Sci-Fi, Superhero, Action, Drama, Fantasy, Adaptation
Length:
2 hr. 6 min.
Year of Release:
2008
USA Release:
May 2, 2008 (wide - 3800 theaters)
Copyright, Paramount Pictures
Copyright, Paramount Pictures
Copyright, Paramount Pictures
Copyright, Paramount Pictures
Copyright, Paramount Pictures
Copyright, Paramount Pictures
Copyright, Paramount Pictures
Copyright, Paramount Pictures
Copyright, Paramount Pictures
Copyright, Paramount Pictures
Relevant Issues

A single man or woman can help change the world. Read about some who did with faith and God's help…
Jesus Christ, Noah, Abraham, Joseph, Moses, and David

Featuring: Robert Downey Jr., Terrence Howard, Gwyneth Paltrow, Jeff Bridges, Samuel L. Jackson, Hilary Swank, Leslie Bibb, Clark Gregg, Stan Lee, Shaun Toub, Nazanin Boniadi, Bill Smitrovich, Ghostface Killah, Faran Tahir, Sahar Bibiyan, Sayed Badreya, Fahim Fazli, Micah A. Hauptman
Director: Jon Favreau
“Elf,” “Made,” “Zathura”
Producer: Victoria Alonso, Ari Arad, Avi Arad, Peter Billingsley, Louis D'Esposito, Jon Favreau, Kevin Feige, Eric Heffron, Michael A. Helfant, Jeremy Latcham, Stan Lee
Distributor: Paramount Pictures

“Heroes aren't born, they're built”

The central myth of the movie “Iron Man” is that of a billionaire playboy whose experience as an incarcerated hostage causes him to transform from an economic and social predator into a born-again pacifist. Stark sees the error of his ways, returns home to confront his personal (and business) demons, and spends the rest of the movie trying to do good, home and abroad. In portraying this action, the writers brilliantly mimic the narrative arc of Robert Downey Jr.’s life as his character, Tony Stark, opens the movie with a glass of scotch on the rocks while bouncing along a dirt road in Afghanistan in a humvee.

In short order, Stark is wounded and captured; his life is saved by an imprisoned Afghani doctor; and in one of the more effective metaphors of the movie, the doctor has to remove bits of Stark Industries shrapnel, remnants of the shards of his professional life, that are threatening his heart. The doctor tells Stark that shrapnel victims are called “the walking dead” because of how the shrapnel migrates through the body and belatedly kills them a week later. When Stark questions why he should do anything to prolong his life if he only has a week to live, the doctor responds (paraphrasing), “Well, it’s the most important week of your life. Don’t waste it.”

That is Tony Stark’s born-again moment and it compels him to create a new heart for himself. For Christian viewers, this new-heart metaphor will resonate with Ezekiel 26:36:

“I will give you a new heart and put a new spirit in you; I will remove from you your heart of stone and give you a heart of flesh.”

This is what happens to Stark and from that point he is determined to correct the predatory aspects of his life, whether it concerns conquering financial markets or seducing beautiful women. He shows little concern for his wealth, for his reputation as an industrialist, or for his company’s stock value. He is truly changed and sees the world through an ethical lens that encompasses not just financial and political issues but moral ones as well. We see a biographical montage of how he progresses from a boy genius to a decadent industrialist to the conscience-stricken inventor who desires to create something to benefit mankind. He indeed has acquired a new heart and a new spirit and his life mimics the pattern of creation (boy genius), fall (decadent industrialist), and redemption (conscience-stricken inventor) that is illustrated so frequently in the Bible through the lives of David, Paul, and Peter, and in the parable of the Prodigal Son, to name a few.

As Robert Downey Jr. states in an interview concerning his own personal problems: “You can’t go from a $2,000-a-night suite at La Mirage to a penitentiary and really understand it and come out a liberal.” [reference]

It is an interesting statement from several perspectives because “Iron Man” is a blend of liberal and conservative trade-offs. Leftist viewers will be gratified that there is an indictment of American arms manufacturing, that American soldiers are shown being killed with American weapons to illustrate the consequences of American “crimes” overseas, and that Tony Stark renounces the military-industrial complex that is in in his own mind. Conservative viewers will be gratified that American soldiers are at least not demonized, that terrorism is a reality, and that Stark undergoes the kind of personal conversion, renouncing sex and drugs, that is characteristic of a conservative ethos which emphasizes personal responsibility. In that regard, the movie brilliantly succeeds in walking the political tight rope of the age and is able to insert a subtle anti-war message where clumsy, anti-war films like“ Rendition,” “Lions for Lambs,” “Grace Is Gone,” and “Stop-Loss”—to name only a few of many movies—failed because they were just anti-American propaganda in disguise.

Finally, that which powers Tony Stark, and by extension, Iron Man, is the new heart which demonstrates love on a personal level and compassion on a global level. As a metaphor, it is elegant; as a line of reasoning to inform something as complicated as foreign policy, it naturally falls apart. In their effort to offend no one and name no names, the writers describe the Afghani terrorists as “foreigners,” completely ignoring the home-grown Taliban who terrorized the country for decades and who just last week tried to assassinate President Karzai, killing three people. The terrorists are called the “ten rings” because they come from ten foreign countries and, in one especially ludicrous moment, one of the terrorists is identified as an Hungarian. Clearly, it is such white Europeans who are to blame for the nameless acts of terror committed in the name of a nameless god which bedevils Afghanistan.

This is not a trivial detail because were it not for the American invasion of Afghanistan in a post-9/11 world, Afghanis today would still be living in a medieval world that forbids soccer, kite-flying, music, movies, and, most importantly, education and medical treatment for women. The movie is profoundly dishonest in that regard and exhibits an ideological hangover that blinds people to the enormous good that American military might has accomplished in freeing and keeping free entire nations, including the whole of Europe, South Korea, and Afghanistan from the totalitarian ideologies of communism, nazism, and Wahabbism. For a more accurate portrayal of the home-grown terrorism of Afghanistan, see “The Kite Runner” or, better yet, read the book.

In conclusion, Iron Man is a triumph of collaborative film making. Although Robert Downey Jr.’s performance has gotten most of the credit for the movie’s success, Jon Favreau’s nearly flawless pacing and the snappy screenplay are responsible for giving Downey a frame in which he doesn’t have to act so much as just be. The perception that Downey’s performance is superb rests more on his comedic timing than it does on his acting chops. This allowed an understated performance to appear nuanced instead of, pardon the pun, mechanical. It is the kind of performance which in the hands of an actor less pitch-perfect (Keanu Reeves) would have resulted in a rotoscoped (“A Scanner Darkly”) performance.

Gwynneth Paltrow as Pepper Potts was sensitive, sweet, and principled, doing as much with her uninspired lines as a charming personality could. Regrettably, Terrence Howard was stiff and Jeff Bridges was unbelievable as a scientist, mad or otherwise. Downey carries the movie, but it is Favreau’s direction that frames him in such a way that even the sequences where Downey says nothing provide visual descriptions of character that are eloquent and convincing.

There is a moment of brief nudity, but there is nothing that should offend even the most sensitive church-goers. While there is no unifying message in the movie as in the recent “Live Free, Die Hard” film which makes a direct appeal to all Americans to band together, “Iron Man” is nonetheless a brilliant success because it appeals to so many different audiences in a time when those audiences are so much at variance with one another.

Violence: Heavy / Profanity: None / Sex/Nudity: Minor

See list of Relevant Issues—questions-and-answers.


Viewer CommentsSend your comments
Comments below:
Positive

Positive - I saw this movie with some folks from my bible study via free passes to an advanced screening. The movie was stunning in every sense of the word! I am sure some comic book elitists will find something wrong with its translation to the screen( they always do), but it is very well made and I enjoyed nearly every moment! I am not going to elaborate at all about plot, storyline or give any spoiler info, however Tony Stark is a rich playboy, smooth talking womanizer. Dont let this scare you. The movie has a few minor curse words, a few sexually charged scenes with no nudity and although it does have a lot of drinking-no one is drunk. The violence factor is in the eye of the beholder, none too bloody but a good bit of combat. Spiritually, this movie has some good points. I would say that it earns its PG13. But is relatively tame in comparison to movies like Transformers that go for uneeded sexual innuendo.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Barrett, age 39

Positive - Cussing was not too bad. Suggestive portion involved taking a woman to bed, not graphic, not appropriate for pre teens.

Overall a thoroughly enjoyable movie, overall positive storyline.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4.5
—David Bunker, age 39

Positive - WOW! What a fantastic movie! I was able to see an advanced screening of this movie and found myself blown away. Rarely does one find a movie that forces them to consider moral issues, yet also has a big enough budget to pull off an amazing script and brilliant special effects. The acting, from all camps, was spectacular, and it didn't hurt that the script was one of the best I have seen in a long time. What impressed me the most, however, was that this movie looked at an issue of morality- one that they could have taken to the extreme left- and allowed the viewer to consider his or her own point of view. Quite honestly, I was completely blown away by this film. See it!
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Tiffany, age 19

Positive - Iron Man is a story of redemption. Tony Stark realizes that he can no longer reconcile what he is about - being a death dealer through his weapons industry. The story unfolds before of us of someone who goes from being a thoughtless, narcissistic, self-absorbed person into one who comes to realize that what he has been about is empty, without honor, and a horror for the innocent who are caught in the wrath of a thoughtless military. The movie has it's moments which are objectionable in the early part of the movie(one sexually explicit scene), but it moves quickly from that to let us into the heart of a man who has been through hell and back, and in the end it is a triumph of what one man, with a change of heart, determination and vision can do.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Jay Rivera, age 54

Positive - Having seen all of the other Marvel comic book movies, I didn't know what to expect coming into this movie. I left very impressed, however. The graphics were great and the storyline was very good, as well. The only objectionable content I can think of would be one scene where Tony and a reporter have sex where, even though you don't see it, it's implied. Robert Downey, Jr., in my opinion, does a great job as Tony Stark and I also enjoyed the back-up roles of Terrence Howard and Gwyneth Paltrow. Overall, great movie and I can't wait to buy on DVD!
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Kurt, age 17

Positive - I liked this movie. It has fun dialog and an interesting but somewhat predictable story line. There is a little foul language throughout and some explicit sexual scenes and innuendo at the beginning. While I could do without much of the sexual content it is used to establish Tony Stark's character as a man who is empty. So while these unmoral activities are portrayed I hope some people see that it is an empty life. Stark does have an internal transformation which manifests itself in his Iron Man suit and his superhero actions. While the change makes him a better man, God is not the reason for the change and we don't necessarily see a full turn for the better in terms of morality or violence. I would recommend this for teens, but probably PG-15 or more.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—J Sargent, age 34

Positive - Enjoyed watching this film on opening Friday night with my wife. I did not have high expectations but was very pleasantly surprised. I remember watching the old Iron Man cartoons when I was growing up. This is an excellent updated version brought nicely to the big screen. The theater was very crowded with lots of children. Due to some rather sensual scenes in the beginning and about 4 or 5 curse words, I cannot whole heartedly recommend this as a family film. However, as a date film this was very entertaining.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4.5
—Bruce Blackburn, age 50

Positive - This is a terrific science fiction flick, and I'm neither a connoisseur nor a great lover of sci-fi. It is as good, in its own way, as Spider Man. I would never have cast Robert Downey Jr in the lead role, yet he pulls it off well. Your reviewer analyzes the movie very well. I think this is an exciting movie worth seeing.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Halyna, age 62

Positive - I didn't know what to expect. It was very interesting to see how the character changes during the movie and how the people around respond to the change. Even though there are some predictable parts, it still kept me interested, until the end. This is worth seeing on the big screen and the CG are done very well! There are a few sexually suggestive comments. The movie deals with terrorism and the consequences of fabricating weapons of mass destruction.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 3.5
—Alrick, age 34

Positive - The film had a very good story line. It was nice to see Robert Downey Jr. make a movie instead of making trouble. He was excellent in playing the part of Tony Stark. The concept of one man can make a difference was a very good conversation point for older kids. The other positive point was seeing Tony Stark change his life/lifestyle and re focus his efforts for good, another good conversation point. There was one brief sex scene that showed no nudity. This is the only reason I would not let my children (11and under) see the movie. Overall, being a big comic book/superhero fan, I thought the movie was well done and very enjoyable.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4.5
—Marc Lombardo, age 39

Positive - This was a very fun movie that our whole family had been looking forward to seeing. (We have 4 boys ages 10-16). There was little objectionable content: a scene of a young lady waking up wrapped in a sheet, in the main character's house (where it is implied sex took place), a few bad words and typical action violence. My 10 yr. old was scared during one scene where it looked like someone was going to be tortured (they weren't). Other than that, we all enjoyed it very much. The main character stands for doing what's right even though it cost him dearly and that's the message that came across loud and clear. Lots of humor, great special effects and lots of action to keep the viewer entertained.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 4.5
—Rachelle Smotherman, age 35

Positive - I agree with most of what the main reviewer said above, and I appreciate their insightful comments on the film's redemptive message ('I will give you a new heart,' etc.). I wouldn't go so far as to say that 'even the most sensitive church-goer' is likely to enjoy the film, but if you enjoyed Batman Begins, Superman Returns, or any of the Spider-Man films and weren't particularly bothered by the various content issues in those films, there's a good chance you'll enjoy Iron Man as well. Stark is certainly a playboy at the movie's beginning, but thankfully the two scenes where this is depicted most vividly are about thirty seconds long at most. Once he is captured by terrorists, he begins to be a changed man, and this seems to be reflected in the content of the film. Again, if you already enjoy this type of film, it's probably worth your time. If (content-wise) you are bothered by any of the other films listed above, you will not feel any differently about this one.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4.5
—John Stanifer, age 22

Positive - I took my 15 yr. old son and his 11 year old friend to see it. We had a blast! We didn't go in there specifically to look for political messages/correctness, nor to look for what is/isn't going on in Iraq/Afghanistan, or why and to whom. If you go to the movie looking for that, then don't go. I personally feel we see enough of that on the news or other media. I think Robert Downey Jr. did an excellent job, and I was surprised he even took the role, due to his ongoing fight with alcohol (I know he has been through a lot with it. And, from what I know from other alcoholics, it IS a daily work in progress). R.D. Jr.'s character is a 'playboy' of sorts, drinks a lot and pretty much has what is called 'no social responsibility' of any kind. He lives/parties off of his dead Father's legacy from manufacturing and selling arms. He picks up one young woman, and there is such a brief thing on the bed before they fall off, it is almost not worth mentioning. The next morning, she is walking through his home ('Tony Stark' is elsewhere) in one of his shirts. Nothing else is seen. Gwyneth Paltrow's character lets the young woman know where her 'place' is. 'Tony' gets captured after a demo of one of his weapons, and finds out during his capture the very weapons he has manufactured are ending up in the hands of the enemy. He is forced to make the weapon he demo'd, and instead makes a way for him and his 'cellmate' to escape. I won't disclose what happens, except that 'Tony' has decided to make a change in his life. There is only one bad word, and that is when Jeff Bridges character is going after 'Tony' and calls him a pr__k. I think something else could have been used. The graphics/special effects were great and seamless. There were several 'belly laughs' while 'Tony' is working on his Iron Man suit. And we sure enjoyed how he communicated with his computers (I wonder how long it will be before things are like that). Being a 55 year old male (I got out of high school in 1972), I remember Black Sabbath's 'Iron Man' in 1970, and kind of thought that it should have been used on 'Tony's' escape from his captors or when he went back after his captors in his very much improved Iron Man suit. The ending was puzzling (Tony gives out his identity to the world
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Jesse Combs, age 54

Positive - My wife and I went to see this movie after checking out the content from a couple of church members whom we trust. We realy enjoyed the movie and although it did have a couple of scenes that portrayed ungodly sexual actions, the overall concept of a man having a 'heart change' was great. I don't remember any taking of the Lord's name in vain or harsh profanity. I grew up reading marvel comics and wanting to find a hero to believe in. Fortunately, Jesus became my real hero when I was a senior in college. Now, whether Ironman, Batman, or Spiderman, I still love them all as imaginary heroes and greatly enjoyed the fantastic effects that truly made Ironman come to life on the big screen. I do think the PG-13 rating should be a guide to parents as some of the images may disturb children. Enjoy!
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4.5
—Pastor Larry, age 60

Positive - I was very happily surprised at this movie. I haven't been to the theatre in a long time and mostly went because I couldn't wait for the great movies that are coming out this Spring/Summer. I really had very little clue what the movie was going to be about. It was fun! A great story and well done. Robert Downy Jr. really did a wonderful job. What charming charisma and whit! The way a super hero should be in my book. (I really liked Michael Keaton's Batman and he kind of reminided me more of that) I love the change that happens in the main charactor. The movie shows that even though weapons are not the answer to the world's problems. Changed lives and a Super Hero !! Go see it, you'll have fun!
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Chris Wileman, age 40

Positive - My family and I completely enjoyed the movie - one worth seeing again. Aside from one scene early on in the movie (as a part of a string of events showing just how egotistical, selfish, and shallow Tony Stark is - as well as the reporter's charater - which involves foreplay, followed by brief non-revealing nudity), there was nothing else particularly offensive. If there was any bad language, I didn't notice it. Little blood was shown, and nothing was gory (the replacing of the devise over Tony's heart that keeps him alive may be squeamish to some, but that is as far as it goes). In terms of re-creating the comic book character, they did an excellent job. The original Stark went through the kidnapping experience in Viet Nam - which was the current event at the time of the comic's creation. So basically, the movie modernized the character but remained true to form. Stark's attitude and lifestyle fit the script - a complete contrast to the gentlemanly nature of Iron Man - which in the comics made his revelation so unbelievable. The bottom line is fans should be pleased. (There is more, but I don't want to spoil the movie.) By the way fans, stay around for the scene after the credits. The humor and special effects fit perfectly with the film. My sides were hurting at one point! We left the theater feeling good. All in all, this was one of the best films I have seen in a long time.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Deanna Marquart, age 37

Positive - I may be a grandmother, but I still love an excuse to see an action flick with my teenage son. We got to the second showing of Iron Man and even though there were technical difficulties, there was no denting this amazing movie. The Christian parallels of redemption are very much apparent. Tony Stark does have an amazing grace sort of experience, but instead of slaves, it's weaponary that is the message. Fast pace, snappy dialogue, relevant humor, and tight CGI action. This movie will surely top Transformers. I have to disagree with the reviewer, I was offended by the flesh flash--I didn't see the point in including it, except to point out the 'trash' aspect. What a great way to lead off summer--a movie that makes us think about war and all its ripples.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4.5
—Pd Webb, age 50+

Positive - Tony Stark was a womaniser in the comic book, and he is one in the beginning of the movie. He is seen in bed with a woman he met for the first time. The nudity wasn't all that offensive but the way he treats women and the sexual movements while they are in bed are much too graphic. I will not be bringing my 7th grader. The language was very offensive and coupled with the bedroom scene and the violence almost pushed me out the door. They did a great job with the movie and I really like the change of heart aspect. THey handel,ed the violence better than any slasher movie and that probably saved them as far as I was concerned. I thought the acting was fantastic, but much of the storyline was unbelievable even in this genre. His antagonist created and learned to master a armor suit in one minute when it took Tony days.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Chris Ransom, age 41

Positive - Hello! I am a comic geek and I loved this film. However, even if I wasn't, I still would have thought this was a great movie. Unfortunately, sometimes in these comic book movies there are elements of cheesiness and things like that, but this movie did not have ANY. The acting was good, the story was believable (for a movie, of course! (though I wish I could make an Iron Man suit myself...)) and the special effects were INCREDIBLE. Also, there were many great comedic elements in this film. I put the moral rating as AVERAGE because in the beginning there is a very vivid scene of 2 people kissing VERY passionately and I would not want my son seeing that. However, the rest of the movie was refreshing and as I recall, there were not many if ANY curse words in it. Great job Jon Favreau and Robert Downey, Jr.!
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 4.5
—John Huie, age 30

Positive - I will not deny that I, myself, have been a comic book fan since I was a kid, and still regularly read X-Men. I am also a believer, and so when I went to see the film, as always, I had my faith in mind. These days, it seems (especially conflicting to me as a writer) that far too many movies (especially the absolutely awful and morally degrading Shoot 'Em Up) these days are immoral, unChristian works on degrading filth, just to be friendly about it. When I first saw the trailers, I was unsure, but God spoke to me before the film, and he told me it was going to alright, and as always, he was right. The film was very positive to watch. The acting was quite good for an action movie, and I would even describe it as 'An action movie with a heart.' Even the brief sex scene was very brief, not to offend most people. The conversion of Tony Stark was inspiring and positive, and it is something that all genuine Christians can relate to (especially with the backlash of making positive choices). In much the same way, we can find solace in the heroism of the story. True courage doesn't just appear in us, we learn it, it grows within us, and we become stronger because of it. It shows a positive take on a seemingly negative genre. It even had some genuinely funny scenes with the helperbot, and although a few of the scenes and design of the evil Iron Man resembled Robocop 2 far too much, I would highly recommend the movie to believer and comic book fan alike.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 3.5
—Hieronymus Dugan, age 27

Positive - Wow! I just went and saw Iron man and I think it's one of the best superheros movies I've seen. I really did not want to see this movie and only went to hang out with friends, but after seeing it I have to agree with most of America: Iron Man rules! Robert Downey Jr. does a superb job of bring Tony Stark/Iron man to life, fully fleshing out his character. His dry humor kept me rolling thourght the movie.In most superhero movies, you always look forward and sometime only care about the times in the 'suit'. But in Iron man, Tony Stark is just as much of a character as Iron man. The other acters did just as just as well, I particurally liked Gwyneth Paltrow's Pepper Potts, and Stan Lee had a really funny cameo this time around. All in all I def. reccomend Iron man. It rocks!


My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Tyler, age 18

Positive - I went and saw this opening night and all the buzz in the theatre was amazing! I did go into the film already reading a christian review so I knew what to expect. HOWEVER there is one scene that just because of that scene I would not take any child to view this film. There is a 'bed romp' scene and it was really agressive and there were 'sounds' made by both people. They did just hop onto the bed and the camera and the people lingered on the bed then fell on the floor on the other side of the bed, but that in itself was just UNCALLED FOR! After that scene, we are shown the next morning and a sheet is just coving up the lovely young ladys bottom, her back and her legs are shown then she walks around the house in his dress shirt, she does have her underwear on. This was just uncalled for, there was no point of the scene. There is also another scene while Stark and his guard as on the plane and they start drinking and the plane turns into a 'club' with pole in the middle of the plane and the flight attentends hike up their skirts and shirts and dance around the pole! WE GET THE POINT THAT HE IS A PLAYBOY! There really are tasteful ways to portray this type of thing. Parents please be aware of this! This review does not mention these scenes at all and I would be highly embarass if I took my child and they encountered these scenes. Even though i do give this movie great ratings, we have to be care what we put infront of our eyes. There really are better and cleaner ways to portray certain people ESPECIALLY when films like these will draw families to them. Other than that, the acting and film making and story line were great! The Special Effects AMAZING!! I would reccommend seeing this in the theatre but be careful with the kids. Maybe view it first and then base what you see on what to do or at least be aware of where the scenes are.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Ben, age 25

Positive - When it comes to today's comic book heroes, Iron Man isn't exactly a household name. That will probably change as word of this film continues to spread. Please understand, this is not a kids movie. As the review indicates, Tony Stark is not exactly a role model. He has little to no care about himself, other people, or his company (although he does have a change of heart later, no pun intended). He drinks, gambles, and is quite the womanizer. In addition to that, I feel like most of the film's constant techno-babble and dramatic situations will fly right over kids' heads. Also this film is not in a tone like Spider-Man, which was generally light and several scenes in costume. Stark spends more time in the movie building his suit, than he does in it (although the action scenes deliver quite well). The cast is excellent, and overall the film is good fun. But this is one for and older, more mature crowd, a'la Batman Begins. Parents should see it first, and then decide. Just because a movie has Marvel comics in front of it, doesn't mean it's automatically kid friendly.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Christopher, age 25

Positive - From a Christian perspective this movie has some areas of concern, especially for younger children. While it is understood that Tony Stark's decadent nature must be portrayed to provide a contrast with his changed attitude after his imprisonment the film shows more than necessary to accomplish that task. In this respect the sex scene, although tame in comparison to most movies, still shows quite a bit of skin both during and after the encounter (which is, in and of itself, more graphic than necessary.) The consumption of alcohol, even after Stark's change of heart, is shown as a normal part of social interaction. Likewise the violence portrayed, especially in the threatened torture of the Afghani doctor, is intense though not overly graphic. That said, for an adult the film is not only entertaining but provides an enjoyable (and satisfying) good guy vs. bad guy story. The transformation of Tony Stark from a nihilistic genius to a repentant hero is convincing and heartening. As noted in the main review there is a strong (and unbalanced) anti-war sentiment here, but our soldiers are portrayed as what they truly are, heroes in their own right. Unlike many of today’s films, we get to see evil men, who commit despicable deeds, get their just deserts in a manner that is encouraging in a world where justice seems to be a thing of the past. The obviously selfless motives of the film’s protagonist only serve to make those moments of the triumph of good over evil even more uplifting. (And yes, when unrepentant, irredeemably evil men are stopped from committing atrocities against innocents it is uplifting.) All in all, one of the best (if not the best) superhero movie to date (and I am a huge fan of superhero movies.) I would only suggest that you not take impressionable children to see it.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Joe Martin, age 53

Positive - Just saw the movie 2 hours ago with my wife and 4.5 yr old daughter. Iron Man is another Marvel comic superhero that made it to the big screen. Unlike the other superhero movies, one can relate that the script has a little Biblical flavor to it-the review by the author is right on the money. Tony Stark resembles a brilliant rich man who after an unfortunate encounter with near death experience, chose to take a different path and use his resources to make a difference in this world. Ironically or IRONMANically, he also received a new heart of sorts which is in line with being born again. The Bible says that everything begins from the heart and from it we choose to do good or evil-sad to say nobody understands it. The next thread of events do not really hammer this new change that just took place and as expected has Hollywood's movie making engine go to work. Even after Tony's change of heart, he was still slick in getting his hands on a glass of scotch. The significant aspect of the change in my view is that he started to care more about the rammifications of his actions and therefore concerned in making his life make a difference instead of selling weapons and don't care. The worst word I heard was SOB, other than that I could not remember anything else. I was very satisfied with this movie and highly recommend it to all ages although from a technical point of view, the ending could've had more punch to it to make a stronger finishing statement. But then again, there's always part 2.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Excellent! / Moviemaking quality: 4.5
—Tades, age 40

Positive - My daughter and I were invited to see this movie for my nephews birthday party. We had a group of about fifteen children and adults. The first 20 minutes or so of the film had me concerned that this was not for children and perhaps not for me. It exploited woman and had a bedroom scene. I felt they could have done a better job on the moral content in the early part of the movie. In fact it could have been left out. Having been given the tickets as a gift and the father of the boy sitting behind me, I gave the movie a little more time before walking out with my daughter. I was pleased to see it quickly take a change and be full of action and amazing special effects. It was quite captivating and we were entertained by the film and it's impressive hero. Most likley there will be a sequel to this one. If there is a next one I will view it first to decide whether or not it is appropriate for children or if we indeed need to skip the first 20-30 minutes of it! If the movie had continued on the way it was headed I would have walked out. Come on Hollywood- it's time to take the trash out'. A good movie like a good restraunt shouldn't start with a bad smell to it.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Jh, age 46

Positive - This movie was sensational one of the best super hero movies I have seen in a long time. The special affects were out of this world and action was non stop. This film kept me on the edge of my seat the whole time I was in the theater. I really liked the message in the movie because it taught you not to be selfish and to use your talents to help others. I would say that this movie can go down as one of the best super hero stories put on the big screen. The story was well written and the cinematography was perfect. The language in the movie wasn't to bad and It was mostly clean except for one sex scene and some women on a plane dancing provocative, but it went by so quick that I didn't have time to become uncomfortable with the scene. The acting in the film was very good. If you are a fan of heroic movies you will not be disappointed. All I can say is; finally a super hero movie done right.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Gene Cooks, age 32

Positive - This movie will probably be my favorite this year because of how well it was done. The turn around from playboy to protector of the people is amazing. The acting and the actors chosen for this film are just amazing. There is comedy, pain, joy, sadness, and one part where you might become a little scared for the characters as they do hero things. In the first 30 minutes there is one questionable scene between Tony Stark and a magazine reporter where they go back to his mansion and make out. But that lasts for maybe ten seconds then it is over. The humor is very clean and every moment is fresh and different than the scene you saw before. And last but not least the story of Tony Stark's life change is just plain wonderful. If I were to see only one movie this summer it would definitely have to be this one. This movie is perfect for practically everyone as long as you are watching out for that one scene you will be fine.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Grayson Stipe, age 17

Positive - I seldom recommend a positive review for any movie but Iron Man is one such movie. As for the objectionable content, at the beginning of the movie Tony Stark engages in a one night stand and drinks copious amounts of alcohol. Stark is also a pompous, ego-centric billionaire. However, this is all cast in a negative light and as the movie progresses Stark repents of both his womanizing ways and ego and becomes a man of character both in his private and public life. My advice is follow the PG-13 rating where children are concerned but older, more discerning (i.e. 13 and up) audiences should be fine. I agree with the review that Iron Man walks the tight rope between pro-war and anti-war with aplomb. I believe the war in Afghanistan is a biblically just war and America ought to be there. However, as a Christian I earnestly pray for the end of hostilities both there and in Iraq and in that sense I am not pro-war. Sometimes, I wonder if we, American Christians, are not a little too quick to support war for the sake of war now days. Ps 120:7 The reviewer criticized the movie for not naming the Taliban but naming the militants the “Ten Rings”. However the “Ten Rings” is pulled right out of the pages of the original comic book. Remembering that we are in a comic book movie, the producers are staying true to the source material and setting us up for sequels rather than denying the reality of the Taliban, IMO. The original comic book origin was set in Vietnam which would make no sense in 2008 and I’m proud of Marvel for setting the movie origin right in the middle of an actual war between America and Islamofacist militants. I also agree with the reviewer that Downey truly carries the movie as Stark. Downey has permanently stamped his image on the role and is the measure by which any other actor in that role will/would be compared. And anyone who is familiar with Downey’s private life can only wonder if he didn’t bring a good bit of his personal experience to his character. I thought Paltrow did a great job as Pepper Pots and the chemistry between her and Downey was just right. Unlike the reviewer, I totally bought into Jeff Bridges “Judas” role in the film. He was completely convincing as a good guy and completely menacing as the bad guy. To me, Bridges really demonstrated his acting range. Of all the movies that have come out so far this year, I recommend this one (with qualifiers noted above) above all the others. And as comic book adaptations go, this is one of the best ever.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—James Taylor, age 37

Positive - I thought this movie was awesome. The way they show the lifestyle of Tony Stark before as an alcoholic playboy and his life changing after a horrific event was very inspirational. The continuity followed the comic book life of Iron Man really well. The sex scene in the beginning could have been left out but I thought it was a really well written movie other than that. One of the biggest messages was that against overwhelming odds, Tony Stark fought to do the right thing no matter what the cost. The whole cast was excellent and Robert Downey Jr. was the best choice for Tony Stark. I cannot wait to see this movie and other Marvel films tie in together for an Avengers film. I definately recommend seeing it and I plan on watching it again within the week. Note: Make sure you stay for after the credits.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Nick Garcia, age 20

Positive - Number 1, this is a PG-13 movie, it will have some content that you would not want a younger child to see. However, if your child goes to public school or watches regular tv he/she has heard and seen all the bad that will happen in this movie. Ok now with that out of the way, the scene at the beginning where he sleeps with the reporter was necessary to show the type of man he WAS and was not explicit in any way. Only 1-3 curse words in the whole movie with b**** being the harshest. This was probably the best movie from a cartoon I have seen since Spidey 3. It had a good moral quality to it and showed that a person can change from whatever they may have been in the past. I WILL be looking forward to the sequel!!
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Larry Barber, age 45

Positive - I thought Iron Man was a great film. Especially for fans of super heros. What concerns me is that the above review states there is no profanity. Many people have obviously taken their children to this based on this statement. It's a statement that is completely false. I heard two SOB's, quite a few damns and one use of the word prick. Do these not qualify as vulgarity. And the reviewers opinion that the no church going christian would find two people rolling around ona bed is beyond me.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Cory, age 30

Neutral

Neutral - I agree with the reviewer that this film has many redeeming features. However, the reviewer really understates the sexual scene at the beginning of the movie which amounted to partially clothed copulation. I was really not pleased since I did not believe it appropriate for young teens -- or older people for that matter. We should not give Hollywood a pass on this kind of deal in a film targeted at young people. The scene was another example of 'driving up on the sidewalk' in that it was completely unncessary for the story line and far too gratuitious. Aside from this objectionable scene, the rest of the movie was OK.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Offensive / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Greg, age 40

Neutral - My husband and I viewed this with our 13 year old son. The film has a strong anti U.S. military message. All in all it was an enjoyable action film. Robert Downey Jr's character Tony Stark is a rich weapons dealer who spends a lot of time drinking and womanizing. When Tony Stark realizes his weapons are being used to kill innocent people he doesn't want to manufacture weapons of mass destruction anymore. Iron Man is not the usual teenage, geek super hero. This is an adult oriented action film. I felt this is Hollywood sending us another pro-liberal anti President Bush message.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—S. Cornett, age 50

Neutral - After reading the Christian Spotlight review of Iron Man, I thought it was safe to take my children to see the film. I was shocked within the first 10 minutes of the film to hear 'son of a b****' and to see the main character of the film having sex with a reporter he met hours earlier. The sex scene was more than suggestive with the female reporter naked or mostly naked on top of the lead character in his bed as they further hurriedly removed clothing. The next scene has the reporter wake up in the man's bed the next morning and then walk around the house looking for the man in only a shirt. I was upset and embarrassed my kids saw this. This movie has great special effects but is not for young children. Had I known what I now know, my 8 and 10 year old children would NOT have seen the film. By the way, in my opinion, the film is a bit anti-American, with a typical Hollywood liberal slant on the realities of world politics.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Offensive / Moviemaking quality: 4
—S. Allen, age 35

Neutral - Saying that any of the anti-war movies mentioned is 'anti-American propaganda' is delusional. Criticizing the behavior and character of the people in charge of our little corner of the material world is not anti-American! Other than that, a decent review of a halfway decent movie.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 2
—Joe, age 52

Neutral - I went to this movie on the asumption that it was better than average with morals. I was truly dissapointed. It had a anti-America tilt. We are at war to defend America from islam etc. This must be accomplished! The movie leads one away from this. The hero seems never to be quiet. At times just rumbling on as if he just likes to hear himself talk. He frequently drinks and acts child like as an adult. Sexual escapades are implied and acted out. For example, He is being interviewed by an attractive lady one moment and the next they are in bed.(It was vulgar.) Another time at a 'party' a girl calls out to him. 'Hello, do you remember me?' His reply was a casual 'No!' You would be brain dead with his life style potrayed throughout the film not to pick up on the past relatiuonship between the two. There are many examples of where and how this film misses the mark. I will not go in to them. I warn you though this is not a family friendly film! Scott D. Vairo
My Ratings: Moral rating: Offensive / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Scott Vairo, age 44

Neutral - To rate this film better than average was a stretch. The movie making quality was excellent, there were times when me and my 15 year old son were amazed at the graphics and technology shown. I was, however, embarrassed and offended more than once. There were many instances, from the beginning and throughout, where the main character was proud of how many women he had been with and how he had forgotten most, if not all, of them. There was a sexual scene, tons of innuendos and many hints of sexual tension. There were many swear words like s.o.b. and the d word throughout. I expected it to be a little cleaner and was disappointed. Like I said, the graphics were amazing and Robert Downy Jr. acted well. The violence was a little graphic for children of any age. It showed some obvious firepower and although they didn't show shooting innocent people directly, they would barely pan out before the shots were fired. Please keep little ones at home since the main parts of the movie were dialogue and setting up for the scenes, which is dull for them. I feel that there were only a handful of scenes where a child under 10 would be interested.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Offensive / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Shirley, age 40

Neutral - Iron man was a funny, well written, and well written movie. BUT it was disgraceful. This movie is, at it's core, about a rich man who has sex w/ dozens of women (while treating them like dirt). There is no redemption to this man. He becomes the 'hero' because he feels guilty about who bought his weapons.Never once in this movie is there any remorse on the way he treated women. If you have no problem watching a movie that degrades women and glorifies having as much sex with as many people as possible, this is the movie for you. If you are trying to raise a child in this whacked out world we live in, this movie will not help, but it will most definitely hurt any Christian perspective on how to treat a women.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Very Offensive / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Nicholas, age 24

Neutral - I would be ambivalent about Iron Man had it not been so completely boring and predictable. On one hand the production quality was fantastic: the effects, lighting, sound, pacing, direction, acting were all great. And to that part of the story that was mechanical, the structure was done correctly. However, if you get past all the necessary but veiled Christological ingredients (self discovery, repentance, self sacrifice) the movie was just... boring. Perhaps I am looking for too much from movies these days, but this thing really didn't sell itself to me. The main character is so cynical his 'conversion' seemed entirely uncomitted. He just seems like the seed on the rocky soil. He does 'right' out of desparation because he knows his life is meaningless but even his 'rightness' is still saturated with hopelessness. The movie pretends to be about repentance but it's the fornication, the booze and the explosions that really are entertaining. For those who haven't seen it... be sure to watch all the way through the credits for a very short scene with Samuel Jackson. It's at the very end of the credit role and is a glipse of perhaps a part II.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 3
—David Sutherland, age 40

Neutral - I have to take issue with the reviewer's statement that '...there is nothing that should offend even the most sensitive church-goers.' That is simply incorrect! The scene in question shows the title character in bed with a woman he met minutes before; they are kissing extremely passionately and pawing each other heavily. The next scene has her walking around the following morning, clothed only in a bedsheet. Even though I don't class myself as 'most-sensitive', I didn't care for this scene, and feel that this scene alone is enough to disqualify the movie for viewing by children. This is one time when the MPAA ratings board has done a better job than the Christian reviewer! I look to sites like this one in trying to determine whether or not a movie is suitable for viewing by my family. I was mislead in this case; I now know to take these reviews with a grain of salt, and to view the reviews of other Christian oriented sites before making my final decision. The reviewer seems to be more interested in trying to philosophize about the meaning of the movie, than in trying to accurately describe the content of the movie.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Offensive / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Jim Bentley, age 41

Negative

Negative - My husband and I went to see Iron Man based on the review offered on this website. We were deeply concerned that the review seemed off-base as to the content of the film. We went because the review suggested no foul language and that there would be nothing offensive even to the sensitive church-goer. We left after about 15 to 20 minutes into the film after having heard the Lord's name used as a swear word (which we view as foul language) and having viewed exceptional levels of provocative 'trashy' behavior being modeled at a level such that no matter the potentially redemptive aspects to later be developed in the storyline they could not be sufficient to redeem these opening sequences. Therefore we walked out. (We are pleased to say that the theater manager kindly honored our request to be refunded when we explained our concerns.) We would describe what we saw portrayed on screen in the early sequences of Iron Man as lewd and seedy and unfit for biblically minded Christian consumption no matter the rest of the story. We feel the reviewer did not correctly portray the potential content of the film for those who seek to guard their hearts and minds.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Offensive / Moviemaking quality: 3.5
—Susan Bedrosian, Ph.d., age 48

Negative - Warning for Christians resolved to 'turn mine eyes from looking at worthless things' (Psalms 119:37), the special effects that everyone is talking about in this movie comes at a price. You, the viewer, will have to endure sexual fornication, prisoner torture, glorified greed/fame, and revenge (packaged as good vs. evil). Save your hard-earned money and don't grieve the Holy Spirit which resides in you (1 Cor. 6:19). Make no provisions for the flesh, to fulfill it's lusts.'(Romans 13:14)
My Ratings: Moral rating: Very Offensive / Moviemaking quality: 3.5
—Stephen, age 35

Neutral - I have to agree with those who found the Reviewer above to have overly downplayed the offensive content of this movie. The bedroom scene is not the only sexually objectionable content. Also, although I expected a balance of conservative and liberal viewpoints, based on the Review, all I received was a typical liberal attack on the military-industrial complex. I can see that kind of propaganda on the mainstream media for free. Why pay good money to see it?
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 3.5
—David, age 45

Negative - After reading so many 'positive' comments, my family went to see this. Not that this movie can control this, but just the previews before the movie were offensive- Mike Myers and Adam Sandler movies-figured we could make it thru those. But we walked out once we saw the main character romping in bed with a woman not even 10 minutes into the movie. We came to see a comic book turned into a movie- the sex scene wasn't in any way necessary. Just another example of how our society just accepts whatever and overlooks morals- as long as the graphics are good. Very disappointing - do NOT see this movie if you are looking for wholesome entertainment for the whole family.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Offensive / Moviemaking quality: 3.5
—Autumn, age 26

Negative - I would of rated this positive (even thought NO ONE is going to win an Oscar for this one) but Hollywood did it again. They ruined an entertaining family film with about 5 minutes of unnecessary sex and profanity. Coarse words (last time I heard anyone use pr**c was in high school) and swearing appropriate for bar. Not to mentioned the absolutely animalistic sex scene that would arouse anyone. Partial nudity or full, no mistake what went on here. Don't take your kids and embarrass yourself as I did. It was an honestly uncomfortable scene to watch with my son. Wait till it comes out on DVD and maybe you can edit the clean version with clearplay.com.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Offensive / Moviemaking quality: 3.5
—Jim, age 52

Comments from young people

Positive - I saw this film last night and I thought it was great. It was well made and Robert Downey Jr. did a great job. I was surprised that such a well made and cool movie could have Christian principles in it, the main part being when Tony Stark changes his entire life and dedicates it to doing good. There was some language in it at the beginning, but I only remember one word after Stark's conversion. Overall, it was a good movie and I will consider getting it when it comes out on DVD.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Sam, age 15

Positive - Honestly, I went into this movie with high expectations and it fulfilled every single one of them. This movie is definitely on my list of favorite movies, and has taken its spot next to the famed and amazing superhero/comic book movies. It has action, romance, comedy all squished into one fantastic movie. It has hardly any cursing and theres about no objectionable content in it. Overall, I thought it was a very clean, well made movie and would I recommend it to anyone.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Alexis, age 16

Positive - Iron Man was amazing! If your looking to start off the summer movie period with a great movie, I'd suggest this one. The special effects and the plot were great and this is by far the best superhero movie ever! The only parts in this movie that were objectional were that the da-n, he-l, bi-ch, and pr-ck were each used only once. And don't believe the people that say that there was a sex scene with nudity. NOT TRUE!! Tony and the reporter were kissing on Tony's bed. Tony had his clothes on and the girl had her shirt and underwear on. Sure you know that they did do it, but it's not shown at all. The only other bad part is that there is a stripper pole on Tony's plane, but with no stripper on it. Only a flight attendant with her full uniform on. I encourage 10 year olds and up to go and see the best film of the year so far, Iron Man.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Matthew Neveras, age 14

Neutral - Overall, I found this movie to have a good message and it was well paced. My only warning would be that the opening scenes were quite offensive and made me seriously regret having brought my younger brother along with me. However, they serve to show the depraved lifestyle of the main character and thankfully the movie cleans up nicely when it enters into the main storyline.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
—Heidi, age 17

Positive - I was very impressed by this movie! Yes, I was offended by the cuss words, but the 'sex scene' as some people have called it, was extremeley brief. In fact what it looked like to me was that they were wildly kissing. Also, since Tony Stark is presented as a playboy going aroud having flings with everyone, it should of said suggestive themes. So, DO see this movie, unless you are easily offended.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Andrew , age 13